Who Builds the Skills?
EMPLOYMENT SERIES PART 02
Britain’s National Record of Achievement asked young people to document what they could offer. But a record cannot teach a trade, guarantee training or create a route into skilled work.
To understand the difference, we need to ask who builds those routes. Some countries have made employers, vocational schools, government and social partners part of the training structure itself. Britain has relied more heavily on fragmented provision and individual initiative.
READ PART ONE A Folder Full of Potential, a Country Short of Jobs ↗01 THE QUESTION BEHIND THE FOLDER
Skills do not appear because we write them down
Part One began with a burgundy folder. Part Two begins with the question behind it: where do skills come from, and who is responsible for building them?
The National Record of Achievement asked a young person to collect evidence of what they could do. That could help them explain their experience. But skill is more than something an individual can write down. It depends on access to instruction, practice, equipment, recognised qualifications and employers willing to train.
Britain’s approach increasingly placed responsibility on the individual: acquire skills, keep a record, present yourself well and compete for work. Other systems have placed more responsibility on the institutions around that person — employers, colleges, government bodies and unions — to shape training and recognise what has been learned.
The distinction is not that one country trains people and another does nothing. It is how consistently those responsibilities are joined up.
02 THE OECD COMPARISON
The UK appears in a thinner-coordination group
The OECD has compared how employers and trade unions participate in vocational training. In its classification, the UK sat in a group where social partners — employers and unions — financed some training initiatives, often on an ad hoc basis. Germany, Austria, Denmark, France, the Netherlands and Switzerland were among the countries in a group where employers and unions managed and funded training programmes.
That classification has limits. It describes social partners’ highest level of involvement across industries on average; it does not capture every training scheme or mean that the UK has no public system, colleges or apprenticeships. The UK is not alone in the lower-coordination group either: Australia and the United States were listed there too.
But the contrast is still useful. In the UK, training has more often depended on the decisions of individual employers, providers and learners. In countries with stronger social-partner roles, there are more formal ways for industries and workers’ organisations to help define what training should cover and how it is assessed.
That is the institutional difference we need to look at — not a simple “Germany good, Britain bad” verdict.
THE RESPONSIBILITY MAP
Who shares the work of building skills?
A simplified comparison of the institutional roles described in OECD research. The UK panel refers to social-partner involvement, not the whole UK education and training system.
03 THE GERMAN DUAL SYSTEM
Training is built into the route
Germany’s dual system combines workplace training with vocational schooling. An apprentice learns practical skills at a company and studies related theory and general subjects at a vocational school. Training rules for recognised occupations are developed and updated through federal government, employer and union involvement, with the Länder responsible for the school side of the system.
The chambers add another layer. They register apprenticeship contracts, check that companies meet training standards and organise examinations. Employers provide workplace training and pay apprentices; public authorities fund the schools, while government, regional bodies, employers and sometimes industry contribute to other parts of the system.
That does not mean the state runs every workshop or every employer has to take an apprentice. German employers choose whether to train. The difference is that those who do operate within shared occupational standards and recognised assessment arrangements. The apprentice is not left to invent a route alone: the training plan, school component and qualification are connected.
PRESSURE DOES NOT ERASE THE BASE
Germany’s apprenticeship market, 2025
The system faces shortages and mismatch too. BIBB reported that youth demand exceeded the supply of training places for a second year.
04 NOT A UTOPIA
A stronger base is not a guarantee
Germany’s training market has come under pressure. In 2025, new apprenticeship contracts fell by 2.1%, the number of places offered declined, and demand from young people outnumbered supply. That means some applicants still cannot find a place, while some employers still struggle to fill vacancies.
The point is not that German institutions prevent every shortage or downturn. It is that a downturn does not erase the standards, chambers, vocational schools and accumulated training relationships already in place. Those are a base from which a country can respond and pivot.
When people say Germany is struggling, that does not make the skills infrastructure disappear. The practical knowledge, occupational standards and training relationships remain part of the productive base — even when the economy is under pressure.
05 JAPAN: PORTFOLIO AND PRACTICAL TEST
A record and a skills test do different jobs
Japan offers another useful comparison. Its school Career Passport is designed to help pupils record and reflect on learning and activities as they move through school. It is a portfolio for career education and self-reflection, not simply a dossier to hand to an employer.
Japan also has a separate National Skill Test. The Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare describes it as a national system for assessing occupational skills; it covers 133 job categories, including machining and carpentry.
That separation matters. A student’s record can help them reflect on their direction. An occupational test can assess whether they have reached a defined level of practical skill. Those are related tasks, but they are not the same task — and a folder cannot replace the training or assessment itself.
Japan should not be treated as a perfect model either. OECD research describes adult training there as heavily firm-specific, with less development of off-the-job training than in many other OECD countries. That can leave workers with skills closely tied to one employer rather than skills that transfer easily between jobs.
06 THE DOUBLE WHAMMY
Income support can help people cope. It cannot build a skills ladder.
This is also where in-work benefits enter the argument. They are not uniquely British. OECD research describes in-work benefits and tax credits as tools used in several countries to support low-income households and make paid work more financially worthwhile. It gives the UK, Belgium, Mexico and the United States as examples of countries that use these tools, while some others rely more on progressive income tax to support lower earners.
There is nothing wrong with helping a household whose earnings are too low to cover its needs. But income support and skills policy do different jobs. A benefit can help with household income; it cannot provide workplace training, give someone a recognised trade qualification or create a progression route.
That is the double whammy. The individual is expected to take responsibility for building and presenting their skills, while public support may be needed to make low-paid work financially sustainable. If training is irregular and progression is uncertain, the person can be left carrying both the responsibility to improve their position and the risk that the available jobs do not let them do it.
This does not mean every in-work benefit is a direct payment to an employer. The OECD’s broader point is that wage floors matter: without them, some of the value of a benefit or tax credit can be captured through lower wages. That is a design risk, not proof of what happens in every workplace.
07 THE ECONOMY BEHIND THE TRAINING
You cannot separate skills from the industries that use them
Training bodies do not exist in a vacuum. They grow around industries, employers, colleges and the work people can actually enter. When manufacturing employment falls and industry-wide training arrangements are narrowed, the skills infrastructure attached to those sectors is put under pressure too.
Parliament’s figures for 1979 to 1985 showed a net fall of about 1.8 million manufacturing employees in Great Britain, alongside growth in service-industry employment. Some work previously done inside manufacturers was also reclassified when firms contracted services out, so the shift should not be read as a simple one-for-one move from factory work to a new service job. But the employment base was changing, and the earlier industry training structure had already been reduced.
Britain’s turn toward private choice and market-led provision did not mean that every service-sector job was unskilled, or that finance created no value. The question is what happened to the technical and occupational ladders that industry once helped organise. If collective training structures are weakened without building equivalent routes elsewhere, workers cannot replace them simply by compiling portfolios, buying a course or being told to take more responsibility.
08 WHAT A SKILLS SYSTEM DOES
A country needs more than capable individuals
The National Record of Achievement focused on the individual: what had you done, what could you offer, how would you present it? Those questions were not pointless. But they could never answer the larger one: who creates the conditions in which people can become skilled?
That requires employers willing to train, institutions that can teach, qualifications that carry meaning, and a reliable connection between learning and real work. Countries organise those responsibilities differently. The OECD comparison suggests that Britain relied more heavily on fragmented or ad hoc involvement from employers and unions, while several European systems gave those groups a more formal part in managing and funding training.
The folder could record potential. It could not build the machinery, the classroom, the apprenticeship or the job that allowed potential to become a skill.
Part One asked why young people were told to keep a record of achievement. Part Two asks what should have stood behind that record: a system with a real stake in building the skills it expected individuals to prove.
References and further reading
- OECD — Collective bargaining, workers’ voice and job quality: social-partner involvement in training
- OECD — Vocational Education and Training Systems in Nine Countries: Germany
- OECD — Germany’s chambers, apprenticeship contracts and examinations
- BIBB — Germany’s apprenticeship market in 2025
- Japan Ministry of Education — Career Passport guidance
- Japan Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare — National Skill Test
- OECD — Japan’s adult learning and firm-specific training
- OECD — In-work benefits, tax concessions and low-paid workers
- OECD — Wage floors and the distribution of in-work benefits
- House of Commons Hansard — Industrial Training Board reforms, 16 November 1981
- House of Commons Hansard — Manufacturing and service employment figures, 10 February 1988
- Office for National Statistics — Long-term trends in UK employment, 1861 to 2018